The in-house vs outsourced IT for nonprofits decision comes down to staff count. Under 50 staff, outsource: one in-house help desk generalist earns a median $61,860 (Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), May 2025), about $88,400 with benefits, more than managed IT for 49 people at $150 per user a month. From 50 to 150 staff, pair one internal IT coordinator with an outside provider; above 150, or when daily on-site work or restricted data dominate, build an internal team. Scottship Solutions built this rule from BLS wage data, a 2023 Kaseya pricing survey, and its own 2026 nonprofit IT spending benchmark.
One IT hire is really one of three roles. BLS May 2025 medians put a help desk generalist at $61,860, a systems administrator at $99,130, and an IT manager at $175,140. Benefits make up 30.0% of total compensation for private industry workers (BLS, June 2026), about 43% on top of wages. A single person covers one of those skill sets during business hours, which is why outsourcing or a hybrid wins below roughly 150 staff.
If the real gap is that nobody owns technology decisions, that is a leadership question for a part-time chief information officer (fractional CIO). A fractional CIO for nonprofits answers it at any size.
What you’ll learn
- Should our nonprofit outsource IT or hire someone in-house?
- What does one in-house IT hire really cost in 2026?
- Is outsourced IT cheaper than one IT person?
- Can your budget carry an in-house IT hire?
- What does this look like for a 40-person nonprofit?
- What is the hybrid IT model for nonprofits?
- When does hiring in-house IT make sense?
- What happens when your only IT person leaves?
- Frequently Asked Questions
- What should you do next?
- Who should own your technology decisions once you pick a model?
- Where do these numbers come from?
Should our nonprofit outsource IT or hire someone in-house?
Start with your staff count. Then check the answer against your budget and your own quotes.
The table below is the staff-count rule in this guide. Each band shows the default model and the math behind it, using BLS wage and benefits data and the Kaseya 2023 price bands covered further down.
| Staff | Default model | The math behind it |
|---|---|---|
| Under 50 | Fully outsourced. Add fractional CIO hours if nobody owns strategy, vendors, or board reporting. | At any per-user price up to $150 a month, managed IT for 49 people ($88,200) costs less than one loaded help desk generalist ($88,400). |
| 50 to 150 | Hybrid: one internal IT coordinator plus an outside provider (co-managed) for security, after-hours, and depth. | At 50 staff, a $101 to $150 contract runs $60,600 to $90,000, which brackets the cost of one generalist. A person on site becomes affordable, but one person still cannot cover security or after-hours alone. |
| Over 150 | Internal team (for example a systems administrator plus a generalist, about $230,000 loaded) with outside specialists and leadership. | At 150 staff, a $101 to $150 contract runs $181,800 to $270,000, which brackets the cost of a two-person team. |
| Any size, overrides | Daily on-site hardware work, or data a third party cannot legally hold, moves you toward in-house sooner. No internal owner of tech decisions means adding a fractional CIO. | Applies regardless of headcount. |
| Budget check | Under about $8M in annual expenses, one loaded generalist costs more than the median nonprofit’s entire reported IT line (1.1% of expenses, Scottship benchmark 2026; line 14 excludes payroll). | $88,400 / 0.011 = about $8.0M |
The break-even sits at about 49 users. One help desk generalist costs about $88,400 a year fully loaded, and managed IT at $150 per user a month for 49 people costs $88,200 a year. Below that headcount, every per-user price up to $150 comes in under the cost of one person.
Two overrides apply at any size. Daily on-site hardware work, or data that a third party legally cannot hold, moves you toward in-house sooner. If nobody inside owns strategy, vendors, or board reporting, add fractional CIO hours whatever your headcount.
Treat this rule as a starting point you check against your own quotes. It is not a law. A quote far outside the price bands below changes the math, so run your real numbers through the same formulas.
Managed IT services vs in-house IT team for a nonprofit with 60 employees
At 60 people, managed IT at $101 to $150 per user per month comes to $72,720 to $108,000 a year. One loaded help desk generalist at about $88,400 lands in the middle of that range. Cost alone does not pick a winner here, so the hybrid band applies: one internal coordinator for on-site work, plus an outside provider for security, after-hours coverage, and depth.
What does one in-house IT hire really cost in 2026?
Ask “which hire?” before you ask “how much?” The person who fixes laptops and resets passwords, the person who runs your servers and network, and the person who sets IT direction are three different BLS occupations with three different pay levels. One hire gives you one of those skill sets.
| Role you might hire | BLS occupation | Median annual wage (May 2025) | Loaded cost at 30.0% benefits share |
|---|---|---|---|
| Help desk / IT generalist | Computer user support specialists | $61,860 | about $88,400 |
| Systems administrator | Network and computer systems administrators | $99,130 | about $141,600 |
| IT manager / IT director | Computer and information systems managers | $175,140 (all employers, skews large enterprise) | about $250,200 |
Salary plus benefits, before recruiting, training, and tools. Sources: BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook pay pages, May 2025 Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics (OEWS) data (pages modified August 27, 2026). BLS Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, June 2026 (released September 9, 2026). Loaded cost = wage / 0.70.
The IT manager median covers all employers and skews toward large enterprises. Read the bottom row as an upper reference point, not a nonprofit going rate.
Benefits add more than most hiring guides assume. The BLS Employer Costs for Employee Compensation release for June 2026 puts benefits at 30.0% of total compensation for private industry workers. Because wages make up the other 70.0%, that works out to about 43% on top of wages.
Here is the arithmetic for the help desk generalist: $61,860 / 0.70 = about $88,400. The same division produces every loaded figure in the table. BLS reports a higher benefits share, 31.5%, for full-time private workers, so the 30.0% basis keeps these numbers conservative.
The loaded figure comes before recruiting, training, and tools. This guide does not put a number on those costs. Add your own estimates on top.
Coverage is the other half of the cost. A full-time schedule is 2,080 hours a year (40 hours x 52 weeks) before any vacation or sick leave, out of 8,760 hours in a year. Locked accounts, failed backups, and suspicious emails do not keep to that schedule.
Is outsourced IT cheaper than one IT person?
Below 50 staff, yes, at any per-user price up to $150 a month. Above that, the quote in front of you decides it.
The only survey-based price distribution we found is Kaseya’s 2023 Global MSP Benchmark Survey of 1,091 managed service providers (MSPs). Two caveats belong next to it. The data is from 2023, and Kaseya sells software to MSPs, so treat it as vendor-published research rather than a neutral price index.
| Per-user monthly price | Share of MSPs | 25 staff | 50 staff | 100 staff | 150 staff |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $50 to $100 | 22% | $15,000 to $30,000 | $30,000 to $60,000 | $60,000 to $120,000 | $90,000 to $180,000 |
| $101 to $150 | 17% | $30,300 to $45,000 | $60,600 to $90,000 | $121,200 to $180,000 | $181,800 to $270,000 |
| $151 to $200 | 11% | $45,300 to $60,000 | $90,600 to $120,000 | $181,200 to $240,000 | $271,800 to $360,000 |
| $201 to $250 | 4% | not shown | not shown | not shown | not shown |
| Over $250 | 1% | not shown | not shown | not shown | not shown |
| Do not price per user | 28% | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a |
Source: Kaseya 2023 Global MSP Benchmark Survey (n=1,091). Annual cost = staff x price x 12. The table shows the per-user bands that fit these staff sizes; Kaseya also reports 16% of providers under $50 (a band it labels per device).
In that survey of 1,091 providers, 16% charge under $50 (a band Kaseya labels per device), 22% charge $50 to $100 per user per month, 17% charge $101 to $150, 11% charge $151 to $200, 4% charge $201 to $250, 1% charge over $250, and 28% do not price per user at all. The shares total 99%, likely because of rounding. Because so many providers price another way, the survey does not give you a typical or median price. Use it to sanity-check a quote, not to predict one.
Now hold your staff row against the $88,400 loaded generalist. At 25 staff, every band through $200 per user costs less than that one person. At 50 staff, the $101 to $150 band runs $60,600 to $90,000, a range that brackets the cost of one generalist.
For what belongs in a contract’s scope and how to read a quote line by line, see our guide to outsourced IT services for nonprofits. To see how the outsourced layer fits with security and strategy, read our overview of managed IT services for nonprofits.
Can your budget carry an in-house IT hire?
Your Form 990 already shows what you report spending on IT. Our nonprofit IT spending benchmark for 2026 analyzed 325,263 Form 990s for tax year 2023 to find what the median nonprofit reports.
| Measure (Form 990 Part IX line 14) | Median |
|---|---|
| IT spend as a share of total functional expenses | 1.1% |
| IT spend per W-2 employee | $1,281 |
| IT spend for $3M to $50M organizations | $81,858 |
Source: Scottship Solutions, Nonprofit IT Spending Benchmark 2026 (325,263 tax year 2023 Form 990 filings, IRS data).
Now run the budget check. One loaded generalist at $88,400 equals 1.1% of about $8 million in expenses ($88,400 / 0.011). Below that, a single hire costs more than the median nonprofit’s entire reported IT line. It also tops the $81,858 median for $3M to $50M organizations.
Two caveats keep this honest. Line 14 excludes tech payroll, telecom, and depreciation, so it understates total technology spending. And only 34.2% of filers report line 14 at all.
What does this look like for a 40-person nonprofit?
Illustrative scenario (hypothetical): this example is built only from the figures in this guide. It is not a client story.
Picture a 40-person nonprofit with two offices and no IT staff. The executive director is choosing between hiring one IT coordinator, signing a managed IT contract, or a mix of both.
| Option | Annual cost | How the cost is built |
|---|---|---|
| One help desk generalist | about $88,400 | $61,860 BLS median / 0.70, before recruiting and training |
| Managed IT at $101 to $150 per user | $48,480 to $72,000 | 40 staff x price x 12 |
| Difference | $16,400 to $39,900 less for managed IT | Before recruiting and training are added to the hire |
Cost is only part of it. When one person handles every ticket, the tickets win. Password resets and printer jams fill the day, while the roadmap, vendor reviews, and board reporting wait.
Two offices make it harder still, because one coordinator can only stand in one building at a time. The recommendation for this scenario: outsource day-to-day operations, and add fractional CIO hours for the roadmap and vendor decisions.
What is the hybrid IT model for nonprofits?
The hybrid IT model splits technology work into three layers. Each layer covers what the others cannot, which is why it fits the 50 to 150 staff band.
- An internal IT coordinator handles on-site work and holds the institutional knowledge. This is the person who knows which program depends on which spreadsheet.
- An outside provider covers monitoring, security, and after-hours support. A team fills the hours and skill sets one employee cannot.
- Fractional CIO hours cover strategy. Part-time leadership sets the roadmap, manages vendors, and reports to the board.
Co-managed IT is the version for a nonprofit that already has one internal IT staffer. Your person stays, and an outside provider adds security, after-hours coverage, and depth. For cost and fit, see our guide to co-managed IT services.
Break-fix support, billed by the hour with no contract, works as a stopgap while you decide. If you already have an MSP and are questioning it, read our guide to MSP alternatives for nonprofits.
When does hiring in-house IT make sense?
Outsourcing does not win everywhere. Hiring in-house is the right call in these situations:
- Above 150 staff. A systems administrator plus a generalist costs about $230,000 loaded ($141,600 plus $88,400). A fully managed contract for 150 people in the $101 to $150 band runs $181,800 to $270,000, a range that brackets the cost of the two-person team, and the team puts people on site.
- Daily on-site physical work at a fixed location, such as hardware that needs hands on it every day.
- Data your legal or compliance framework does not allow a third party to hold.
- A highly custom environment that runs on deep internal knowledge.
Even then, one person is a single point of failure. Pair the hire with outside specialists for security and after-hours coverage, and make sure someone owns leadership, whether that is an internal manager or fractional CIO hours.
What happens when your only IT person leaves?
They take with them whatever lives only in their head and their inbox. The fix costs nothing and works under any model: the organization, not one person, holds the keys.
These accounts should be owned by the organization, not tied to one person’s email:
- Admin credentials for every system
- The domain registrar account
- The Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace global admin
- Vendor and software license accounts
- Backups and the accounts that control them
Require documentation now, whichever model you choose. Whoever is on the way out, an employee or a provider, hands over a written inventory of systems, accounts, licenses, and backups before the last day.
Underneath the hire-or-outsource question sits a bigger one: who owns your technology?
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it cheaper for a nonprofit to outsource IT or hire one IT person?
Below 50 staff, outsourcing is cheaper. One help desk generalist costs about $88,400 a year with benefits (BLS May 2025 wages, June 2026 benefits data), and managed IT for 49 people at $150 per user per month costs $88,200. From 50 to 150 staff, the costs converge and a hybrid model fits best.
Which is better, nonprofit IT consulting or in-house IT support?
In the nonprofit IT consulting vs in-house comparison, staff count decides it: outside support wins below 50 staff, a hybrid wins from 50 to 150, and an internal team wins above 150. The other question is whether you need hands or leadership. Scottship Solutions works on the leadership side as a fractional CIO, setting the roadmap and managing vendors whichever support model you pick.
We are a $4M nonprofit with 25 staff and no IT person. Who should handle our IT?
Outsource. Managed IT for 25 staff at $50 to $150 per user per month costs $15,000 to $45,000 a year. One loaded help desk generalist at $88,400 would equal 2.2% of $4M in expenses, double the 1.1% median reported IT line in Scottship’s 2026 Nonprofit IT Spending Benchmark of 325,263 Form 990s. Add fractional CIO hours if nobody on staff owns technology decisions.
Can a nonprofit have both outsourced and in-house IT?
Yes. The hybrid model pairs an internal coordinator for on-site work with an outside provider for monitoring, security, and after-hours coverage, plus fractional CIO hours for strategy. It is the default for nonprofits with 50 to 150 staff. Co-managed IT is the version for a nonprofit that already has one internal IT staffer.
What is the biggest risk of relying on one internal IT person?
A single point of failure. One full-time person works 2,080 scheduled hours out of the 8,760 in a year, covers one skill set, and without clear rules ends up holding every admin password. If that person leaves without a written handover, the access goes with them.
What should you do next?
- Find your band: Count your staff and locate your row in the staff-count table above.
- Price the real hire: Pick the BLS role you would actually hire and divide the median wage by 0.70 for the loaded cost.
- Price the contract: Multiply each quote’s per-user price by your staff count and by 12, then compare it to the loaded hire.
- Run the budget check: Compare the loaded hire with 1.1% of your total expenses and with your own Form 990 line 14.
- Secure the keys: Move admin, domain, and license accounts into organization-owned accounts this month, whichever model you choose.
Who should own your technology decisions once you pick a model?
Picking a model settles who answers the tickets. It does not settle who sets the roadmap, manages vendors, and reports to the board. Without an owner, those decisions fall to whoever is closest to the problem that week.
Need someone to own your technology decisions?
Scottship Solutions serves as a fractional CIO for nonprofits, setting the IT roadmap, managing vendors, and reporting to the board, whichever support model you choose.
Where do these numbers come from?
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook: Computer Support Specialists: computer user support specialists median annual wage $61,860 (May 2025 OEWS data, page modified August 27, 2026).
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook: Network and Computer Systems Administrators: median annual wage $99,130 (May 2025).
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook: Computer and Information Systems Managers: median annual wage $175,140, all employers (May 2025).
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, The Economics Daily: compensation costs for private industry workers, June 2026 (published September 17, 2026): benefits were 30.0% of total compensation for private industry.
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, June 2026 (released September 9, 2026): benefits 30.0% of total compensation for private industry, 31.5% for full-time private workers.
- Kaseya, 2023 Global MSP Benchmark Survey (n=1,091): pricing shares of 16% (under $50, labeled per device), 22% ($50 to $100 per user), 17% ($101 to $150), 11% ($151 to $200), 4% ($201 to $250), 1% (over $250), and 28% that do not price per user.
- Scottship Solutions, Nonprofit IT Spending Benchmark 2026: median Form 990 Part IX line 14 IT spend of 1.1% of total functional expenses, $1,281 per W-2 employee, $81,858 for $3M to $50M organizations; 34.2% of filers report line 14 (325,263 tax year 2023 filings).
